SEC Charges More Public Companies for Confidentiality Agreements That Might Deter Whistleblowers
In the past two years, the SEC has charged six public companies with violating SEC Rule 21F-17, which prohibits confidentiality agreements that could impede employees from making whistleblower claims directly to the SEC. Since the Employment Law Observer reported on the SEC’s first case attacking a confidentiality agreement., the SEC has charged five more companies with Rule 21F-17 violations. In each case, the employer had confidentiality or severance agreements that either: (a) purported to limit the types of information that an employee may convey to the SEC or other authorities; or (b) required departing employees to waive their rights to any individual monetary recovery in connection with reporting information to the government. The employers settled the cases by, among other things, amending the agreements and paying a significant civil penalty.
Rule 21F-17 has been effective since August 12, 2011. The rule was issued by the SEC in connection with the The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act. The Dodd-Frank Act amended The Securities Exchange Act of 1934 to add Section 21F, “Whistleblower Incentives and Protection,” to encourage whistleblowers to report possible violations of the federal securities laws directly to the SEC. The SEC implemented its new authority under Section 21F by issuing Rule 21F-17, which provides, in relevant part, that “no person may take any action to impede an individual from communicating directly with the Commission staff about a possible securities law violation, including enforcing, or threatening to enforce, a confidentiality agreement . . . with respect to such communications.”
On October 16, 2016, the SEC’s Office of Compliance Inspections and Examination released a risk alert that employers should consider in reviewing whether their confidentiality and severance agreements comply with Rule 21F-17. Even though the alert is directed to SEC regulated investment advisers and broker-dealers, the guidance applies to any employer with confidentiality agreements.
According to the risk alert, the SEC will review provisions of confidentiality or other agreements required by employers that contain language that, either by itself or under the circumstances in which the agreements are used, impedes employees and former employees from communicating with the SEC regarding possible securities law violations. The risk alert gives examples of problematic provisions, including:
- requiring employees to forfeit all benefits if they violate any of the terms of the agreements;
- requiring employees to represent that they have not assisted in any investigation involving the employer;
- prohibiting against disclosures of confidential information without any exception for voluntary communications with the SEC concerning possible securities laws violations;
- requiring employees to notify and/or obtain consent from the employer before disclosing confidential information without any exception for voluntary communications with the SEC concerning possible securities laws violations; and
- purporting to permit disclosures of confidential information only as required by law without any exception for voluntary communications with the SEC concerning possible securities laws violations.
The SEC’s enforcement actions show that it will aggressively protect whistleblowers’ rights and its access to their information. In fact, in five out of the six cases, there was no evidence that anyone was prevented from communicating directly with the SEC about potential securities laws violations or that any agreements were enforced to prevent communication with the SEC.
Confidentiality provisions are critical to most employers’ business and are typically recommended by counsel and human resource professionals. It is necessary to review the language in those provisions, however, to ensure that the agreements comply with the existing and ever-changing state and federal laws. Overbroad provisions or language which may be read to prevent an employee from lawfully reporting or communicating with a government agency regarding allegedly illegal conduct is could be unenforceable, which could lead to an entire agreement rendered void.
Ken Yeadon is a former SEC Enforcement Attorney and Assistant U.S. Attorney. If you have questions about the SEC, Rule 21F-17, confidentiality agreements, or employment agreements in general, please contact Ken in our Chicago office at (312) 704-3524 and kyeadon@hinshawlaw.com, or your regular Hinshaw lawyer.
Topics
- #12Days
- #MeToo
- 100% Healed Policy
- 10th Circuit Court of Appeals
- 11th Circuit Court of Appeals
- 17200
- 1st Amendment
- 1st Circuit Court of Appeals
- 2015 Inflation Adjustment Act
- 2018 Withholding Tables
- 24-Hour Shifts
- 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals
- 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals
- 42 U.S.C. s. 1981
- 42 U.S.C. ยง 12203(b)
- 42 USC 1983
- 4th Circuit Court of Appeals
- 5th Circuit Court of Appeals
- 62 USC 623
- 6th Circuit Court of Appeals
- 7th Circuit Court of Appeals
- 8th Circuit Court of Appeals
- 9th Circuit Court of Appeals
- A.A.R.P. vs. U.S. E.E.O.C.
- AB 1008
- AB 749
- ACA
- Accommodation
- accomodate
- ADA
- ADA Interference
- ADA Litigation
- ADAAA
- ADEA
- Administration
- Administrative Exemption
- Administrative Warrant
- Adverse Employment Action
- Affirmative Action
- Affordable Care Act
- Age Discrimination
- Age Discrimination in Employment Act
- Age-Based Harassment
- Agreements
- AHCA
- Aiding and Abetting
- Ambulance Attendant
- AMD
- American Health Care Act
- Americans with Disabilities Act
- Amusement Parks
- Annual Summary
- Anti-Discrimination Policy
- Anti-Harassment
- Anti-Harassment Policy
- Anti-Retaliation Rule
- Anxiety
- Arbitration
- Arbitration Agreement
- Arrest Record
- At-Will Employment
- Attorney Fees
- Attorney General Guidance
- Audit
- Automobile Sales Exemption
- Baby Boomers
- Back Pay
- Background Checks
- Ban the Box
- Bankruptcy
- Bankruptcy Code
- Bargaining
- Bargaining Unit
- Baseball
- Belmont CA Minimum Wage
- Benefits
- Bereavement
- Biometric Information
- Biometric Information Privacy Act
- Black Lives Matter
- Blocking Charge Policy
- Board of Directors
- Borello Test
- Breastfeeding
- Browning-Ferris
- Burden of Proof
- Burden Shifting
- CAFA
- California
- California Court of Appeal
- California Department of Fair Employment and Housing
- California Employment
- California Fair Employment and Housing Act
- California Family Rights Act
- California Labor Code
- California Labor Code s. 226.2
- California Labor Code s. 230.1
- California Labor Code Section 1197.5
- California Legislature
- California Minimum Wage
- California Senate Bill 826
- California Supreme Court
- Caps
- Case Updates
- Cat's Paw
- CFAA
- Chicago Minimum Wage
- Child Labor Laws
- Childbirth
- Choice of Law
- Church Plans
- Circuit Split
- City of Los Angeles CA Minimum Wage
- Civil Rights
- Claim for Compensation
- Class Action
- Class Action Waiver
- Class Arbitration
- Class Certification
- Class Waiver
- Code of Conduct
- Collective Action
- Collective Bargaining
- Collective Bargaining Agreements
- Collective Bargaining Freedom Act
- Committee on Special Education
- common law
- Commuting Time
- Comparable Work
- Compensable Time
- Compensation History
- Complaints
- Compliance Audit
- Computer Exemption
- Confidential Information
- Confidentiality Agreement
- Constructive Discharge
- Consular Report of Birth Abroad
- Contraception Services
- Contraceptive
- Contracts Clause
- Conviction Record
- Convincing Mosaic
- Cook County
- Cook County Minimum Wage
- Corporate Board
- Corporations
- Criminal Conviction
- Criminal History
- CSE
- Customer Service
- D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals
- DACA
- Damages
- Deaf
- Defamation
- Defendant Trade Secrets Act of 2016
- Delaware
- Department of Homeland Security
- Department of Economic Opportunity
- Department of Justice
- Department of Labor
- Department of Workforce Development
- Designation Notice
- Direct and Immediate
- Disability
- Disability & Medical Leave
- Disability Discrimination
- Disability-Based Harassment
- Disciplinary Decisions
- Discrimination
- Discrimination and Harassment
- Disparaging
- Disparate Impact
- Disparate Treatment
- District of Columbia
- Diversity
- Diversity Policy
- Documentation
- Dodd-Frank
- Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act
- DOJ
- DOL
- Domestic Violence
- DOT
- Drug Free Workplace Act
- Drug Free Workplace Policies
- Drug Testing
- Dues
- Duluth
- DWD
- E-Verify
- EAP Exemption
- Earned Sick and Safe time
- Eavesdropping
- Education
- EEO Laws
- EEO-1
- EEOC
- El Cerrito CA Minimum Wage
- Election
- Electronic Communication Policy
- Electronic Communications
- Electronic Reporting
- Eleventh Circuit
- Emeryville CA Minimum Wage
- Emotional Distress
- Employee
- Employee Benefits
- Employee Handbook
- Employee Termination
- Employer
- Employer Health Care Plans
- Employer Mandate
- Employer Policies
- Employer Policy
- Employer Sponsored
- Employer-Employee Relationship
- Employment
- Employment Contract
- Employment Verification
- Enterprise Coverage
- EPA
- Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
- Equal Pay Act
- Equal Pay for Equal Work
- Equal Protection
- Equality
- ERISA
- ERISA section 4(b)(2)
- Essential Employment Terms
- Essential Functions
- ESST
- Estoppel
- Ethnic Equality
- Evidentiary Burdens
- Exclusive Remedy
- Executive Exemption
- Executive Order
- Exempt Employee
- Exempt Status
- Exemption
- Exhaustion of Remedies
- Experience
- Expert
- Expression of Milk
- Extreme or Outrageous
- FAA
- Failure to Accomodate
- Fair Credit Reporting Act
- Fair Employment and Housing Act
- Fair Labor Standards Act
- Fair Pay
- Fair Reading
- Fair Workweek Law
- Fair Workweek laws
- Fairfax Memo
- Family Medical Leave Act
- family planning
- Fast Food
- FCRA
- Federal
- Federal Arbitration Act
- Federal Contracts
- Federal Government
- Federal Register
- FEHA
- fertility
- FICA
- Fiduciary
- Fiduciary Duty
- Fiduciary Rule
- Fifth Circuit
- Final Rule
- Fines
- fingerprints
- First Amendment
- Fitness-For-Duty
- Flexible Spending Accounts
- Florida
- Florida Civil Rights Act
- FLSA
- FLSA Exemptions
- Flu Shot
- FMCSA
- FMLA
- FMLA Abuse
- FMLA Interference
- Form 300A
- Forum-Selection Clause
- Fourteenth Amendment
- Franchisee
- Franchising
- Franchisor
- Fraud
- Freedom of Speech
- FSA
- Full-time hours
- garden leave clause
- Gay Rights
- Gender Bias
- Gender Discrimination
- Gender Equality
- Gender Identity
- Gender Identity Discrimination
- Gender Identity-Based Harassment
- Gender Nonconformity
- Generation Z
- Generational Conflict
- Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act
- Georgia
- Gig Economy
- Gig Worker
- GINA
- Goods vs. Materials
- Graduate Students
- Grievances
- Grocers
- Gross
- H-1B
- Hair Discrimination
- Handicap Discrimination
- Harassment
- Hawkins-Slater Medical Marijuana Act
- Health Care
- Health Care Employers
- Health Care Provider
- Health Insurance
- HHS
- Highly Compensated Employees
- HIPAA
- Hiring
- Hiring Policy
- Hiring Practices
- HIV
- Hostile Work Environment
- Hour Tracking
- Hours Worked
- HR
- Human Trafficking
- Hybrand
- I-9
- IDHR
- IEP
- Illinois
- Illinois Department of Human Rights
- Illinois Human Rights Act
- Illinois Minimum Wage Law
- Illinois Nursing Mothers in the Workplace Act
- Illinois One Day Off In Seven Act
- Illinois Supreme Court
- Immigration
- Impaired
- Impairment
- Incentives
- inclusion
- Income Tax
- Independent Contractor v. Employee
- Independent Contractors
- Indiana
- Individualized Education Program
- informed consent
- Injuctive Relief
- Injunction
- Injuries
- Injury and Illness Reporting
- Interactive Process
- Interference
- Intermittent Leave
- Internal Applicants
- Internal Complaints
- Internal Revenue Service
- Interns
- Internships
- Investigation
- Iraq
- Iris Scans
- IRS
- IRS Notice 1036
- ISERRA
- Jefferson Standard
- Job Applicant
- Job Classification
- Job Classification Audit
- Job Descriptions
- Joint Control
- Joint Employer Test
- Joint Employers
- Joint Employment
- Judicial Estoppel
- Klever v. Carefusion
- LAB s. 226.2
- Labor
- Labor and Employment
- Labor Code
- Labor Dispute
- Labor Organizing
- Lactation Accommodations
- Lactation Policies
- Las Vegas
- lateral transfer
- Layoff
- Leased Employee
- Leave
- Ledbetter Act
- Legislation
- Lesbian Rights
- LGBTQ
- LGBTQ Rights
- LMRA
- Local Ordinance
- Los Angeles County CA Minimum Wage
- Loss of Consortium
- M.G.L. Chapter 151B
- Major League Baseball
- major life activity
- Malibu CA Minimum Wage
- Mandatory
- Mandatory Arbitration
- Manufacturers
- Marijuana
- Marital Discrimination
- Maryland Minimum Wage
- Massachusetts
- Massachusetts Equal Pay Act
- Massachusetts Pregnant Workers Fairness Act
- Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court
- Massachusetts Wage Act
- Maternity Leave
- McDonnell Douglas
- Meal & Rest Break
- Meal Breaks
- Meal Period
- Media Mention
- Medical Condition
- Medical Examination
- Medical History
- Medical Marijuana
- MEPA
- MHRA
- Michigan
- Micro-Units
- Military
- Military Duty
- Millennials
- Milpitas CA Minimum Wage
- Minimum Wage
- Ministerial Exception
- Minneapolis Minimum Wage
- Minneapolis Sick and Safe Time ordinance
- Minneapolis, Minnesota
- Minnesota
- Minnesota Court of Appeals
- Minnesota Human Rights Act
- Minor Employees
- Minors
- Misappropriation
- Misclassification
- Missouri
- MLB
- Montana Human Rights Act
- Montgomery County Maryland Minimum Wage
- Mount Lemon Fire District v. Guido
- MSHA
- Multiple Sclerosis
- Municipalities
- Narrow Construction
- National Football League
- National Labor Relations Act
- National Labor Relations Board
- National Origin Discrimination
- Natural Hair
- Nebraska
- Negligence
- New Jersey
- New Jersey Compassionate Use Medical Marijuana Act
- New Jersey Law Against Discrimination
- New Moms
- New York
- New York Average Weekly Wage
- New York City
- New York City Human Rights Law
- New York Labor Law
- New York Legislation
- New York Paid Family Leave
- New York State Human Rights Law
- News
- NFL
- NJ Paid Sick Leave Law
- NJDOL
- NJLAD
- NLRA
- NLRB
- No Rehire Provisions
- Non-Compete
- non-competition agreement
- Non-Employee Union Agents
- Non-Supervisory Employees
- nonproductive time
- Notice
- Notice of Proposed Rule Making
- NPRM
- Nursing Mothers
- NY State Department of Taxation
- NYSHRL
- Obama Administration
- ObamaCare
- Obesity
- Objectively Offensive
- Occupational Safety and Health Administration
- OFCCP
- Off-Duty Rest
- Off-the-Clock
- Office of Management and Budget
- Ohio
- Ok Boomer
- Oklahoma
- Older Workers
- OMB
- On-Call Scheduling
- Only When Rule
- Opinion
- Opinion Letter
- Opposition
- Oregon Minimum Wage
- OSHA
- Other-than-Serious Violation
- Outside Applicants
- Outside Sales Exemption
- Overtime
- OWBPA
- PAGA
- Paid Leave
- Paid Sick Leave Law
- Paid Sick Time
- Paid Time Off
- Parental Leave
- part-time hours
- Partnership
- Pasadena CA Minimum Wage
- Patient Protection and Affordable Health Care Act of 2009
- Pay Data
- Pay Equity
- Pay Gap
- Pay History
- Pay Inquiries
- Payroll
- Payroll Taxes
- PDA
- Penalties
- Pennsylvania Minimum Wage Act
- Pennsylvania Wage Payment and Collection Law
- Pension
- Pension Plans
- Perceived Disability
- Permanent Replacement Employees
- Personnel Record
- PFL
- Physiological Condition
- Picket
- Piece-rate
- Policies
- Policy
- Political Affiliation
- Political Discrimination
- Politics
- Polygraph
- Portland Maine Minimum Wage
- Posting Requirements
- Preemption
- Pregnancy Discrimination
- Pregnancy Discrimination Act
- Pregnant Worker Protections
- Premium Wage
- President Obama
- Presidential Election
- Pretext
- Preventative Care
- Privacy
- Private Colleges and Universities
- Private Employers
- Private Property
- Professional Exemption
- Property Rights
- Proposed Rulemaking
- Protected Activity
- Protected Class
- Protected Concerted Activity
- Protected Speech
- PTO
- PTSD
- Public Employers
- Public Records
- Publicly-Held Corporations
- Punitive Damages
- qualified individual
- Quid Pro Quo
- Race Discrimination
- Racial Discrimination
- Racial Equality
- Racial Harassment
- Reasonable Accomodation
- Recess Appointment
- Reduction in Force
- Regarded As
- Rehabilitation Act
- Religion
- Religious Discrimination
- Religiously Affiliated Employers
- Removal
- Reporting
- Reporting Time Pay
- Reproductive Health
- Republican
- Request for Information
- Respondeat Superior
- Rest Breaks
- Rest Period
- Restaurants
- Restrictions
- Retail
- Retaliation
- retaliatory termination
- Retina Scans
- Rhode Island
- RICO
- RIF
- Right to Control
- Right-to-Sue
- Right-to-Work
- Rounding Policy
- Safety Programs
- Salaried Employees
- Salary History
- Salary Inquiries
- Salary Inquiry
- Salary Test
- Salespersons
- San Francisco CA Minimum Wage
- San Francisco Parity in Pay Ordinance
- San Leandro CA Minimum Wage
- Sanctions
- Santa Monica CA Minimum Wage
- Sarbanes-Oxley Act
- SB 1300
- SB 1343
- SB 749
- SB 778
- SB 826
- SB1343
- SCA
- SCOTUS
- Seasonal Workers
- SEC
- Secretary of Labor
- Secretary Solis
- Section 1983
- Section 7
- Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act
- Section 8
- Securities & Exchange Commission
- Securities Fraud
- Self Evaluations
- Seperation
- Serious Health Condition
- Serious Violation
- Settlement Agreement
- Seventh Circuit
- Severance
- Severe and Pervasive
- Sex Discrimination
- Sex Stereotyping
- Sex-Based Harassment
- sexual and reproductive health decisions
- Sexual Assault
- Sexual Harassment
- Sexual Orientation Discrimination
- Sexual Orientation-Based Harassment
- Shameless
- Short-Term Disability
- Sick Leave
- Similarly Situated
- Social Media
- Social Media Policy
- Social Security
- South Dakota
- SOX
- Split Shift Pay
- SSA
- St. Paul Sick and Safe Time Ordinance
- St. Paul, Minnesota
- Stalking
- Standing
- State Government
- State of Nevada v. US Department of Labor
- Statute of Limitations
- Statutory Exemption
- STD prevention
- Stock
- Street Trade Permits
- strike
- Student Loans
- Students
- Subjectively Offensive
- Subpoena
- Substantial Relationship
- Supervisor
- Supervisor Reassignment
- Supervisors
- Supervisory Employees
- Supplemental Wages
- Supreme Court
- Supreme Court of the United States
- Tax
- Tax Credits
- Tax Cuts and Jobs Act
- Tax Implications
- Tax Reform Act
- Teenage Labor
- Temporary Employee
- Temporary Help Agency
- Temporary Schedule Change
- Temporary Workers
- Termination
- Texas
- Texting
- Third Circuit
- Time Clock
- Time Records
- Tipped workers
- Title IX
- Title VII
- Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964
- Title VII Retaliation; Faragher/Ellerth
- Tort Liability
- Trade Secrets
- Training
- Trans
- Transgender Rights
- Transitioning
- Transportation Industry
- Travel Time
- Trial
- Trump
- Trump Administration
- U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
- UCL
- Undergraduate Students
- Undocumented Workers
- Undue Hardship
- Unemployment
- Unfair Labor Practice
- Union Dues
- Union Organizing
- Union Relations Privilege
- Unions
- Unit Clarification Petition
- Unlawful Employment Practice
- Unpaid Leave
- Unpaid Wages
- USCIS
- USERRA
- vacation
- Vacation Accrual
- Vacation Pay
- Vacation Policy
- Vaccination
- Vaccine Requirement
- VEBA
- Verdict
- Vested Rights
- Vicarious Liability
- Virginia
- Voluntary
- Volunteer Programs
- Volunteering
- Volunteers
- Wage and Hour
- Wage Order 7
- Wage Order 9
- Wages
- Waiting Period
- WARN
- Webinar
- Wellness
- Wellness Program Incentives
- Wellness Programs
- WFEA
- Whistleblower
- White House
- Willful and Repeat
- Wis. Stat. ch. 102
- Wisconsin
- Wisconsin Court of Appeals
- Wisconsin Fair Employment Act
- Withholdings
- Witness Statements
- Work Permits
- Work Restriction
- Work Schedules
- Workers Compensation
- Workplace Bullying
- Workplace Discrimination
- Workplace Disputes
- Workplace Injury
- Workplace Injury Reporting
- Workplace Policies
- Workplace Rules
- Workplace Training
- Wright Line
- written release procedures
- Wrongful Termination
- Zarda v. Altitude Express